Go back

Neither Code nor Conspiracy: Where This Series Stands

How this series differs from the “Ratzinger Code,” Archbishop Viganò, Ann Barnhardt, sedevacantism, and recognize-and-resist, and why the differences matter.

Date
Category
Papacy, Opinion
Reading time
11 min

Why This Essay Is Needed

Anyone who argues in public that Benedict XVI never validly resigned will be filed, within minutes, alongside everyone else who has said something similar. Some of those voices are serious and some are not. Some write in good faith and some are selling something. And some who reach a conclusion near ours arrive by roads we believe lead nowhere, or somewhere worse.

Essay 2 laid out our argument and tested it against its strongest objections. Before we take up the weightiest objection of all, the Church’s acceptance of Benedict’s successor, readers deserve to know whose company we are and are not keeping. This is not a matter of manners. An argument is judged partly by the methods of those who make it, and a sound conclusion reached by unsound means does the truth no favors.

So this essay sets our position beside five others a reader is likely to meet: the “Ratzinger Code” of Andrea Cionci, the case made by Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò, the writings of Ann Barnhardt, sedevacantism, and the posture usually called “recognize and resist.” In each case we state the position as fairly as we can, note what we share with it, and explain where we part company, and why.

Our Method in Four Commitments

First, the measuring stick. The argument of this series rests on four commitments, and every comparison below comes back to them.

  1. We argue only from public words. Our evidence is what Benedict XVI and his secretary said openly: in a general audience, in published interviews, in a lecture at a pontifical university. We do not decode hidden messages, and we do not claim to know anyone’s private thoughts.
  2. We argue from law, not from interior states. Canon 188 voids a resignation made in substantial error, and substantial error can be shown from what a man publicly says he is doing. Fear, malice, and secret intentions live in the conscience, which no one but God can read.
  3. We take Benedict at his word. He was a true pope who, we believe, erred about the nature of his own act. He was not a schemer, a liar, or a heretic, and we will not call him any of those things.
  4. We ask a narrow question and leave the verdict to the Church. Our claim concerns one juridical act on one day in 2013. As Essay 1 explained, a Catholic may ask such a question and give his reasons, but he may not appoint himself the tribunal that settles it.

I. The “Ratzinger Code”

The Italian journalist Andrea Cionci has done more than anyone to popularize the idea that Benedict never resigned. His 2022 book Codice Ratzinger reached a wide audience, and in June 2024 he filed a petition with the tribunal of Vatican City State asking it to declare the renunciation null1. The first two parts of that petition will look familiar to readers of Essay 2. They rely on Stefano Violi’s early reading of munus and ministerium, and on the substantial-error clause of canon 188.

But Cionci’s own explanation of what happened lies in the third part, and it is a very different account from ours. On his reading, Benedict “never wanted to abdicate.” Cornered by enemies, and having perhaps, Cionci alleges, been drugged during a trip to Cuba in 2012, Benedict deliberately renounced only the ministerium so as to place the Church in a state of “impeded see,” leaving whoever followed him an antipope. The text of the Declaratio, on this view, is a carefully constructed message whose apparent oddities were planted so that the faithful would one day see through them.

This is where we part company with this thesis at its foundation, and the reason is not a matter of taste. Cionci’s account and ours are not two sides of the same coin. Rather, they innately contradict each other.

Substantial error means that a man does something other than what he thinks he is doing. Our case is that Benedict sincerely believed he could lay down the governance of the Church while maintaining a bond to the Petrine office, and that he was mistaken. Cionci’s case is that Benedict knew exactly what a valid resignation required and deliberately withheld it. If Cionci is right, there was no error at all. There was a plan. And a plan to appear to resign while secretly remaining pope would require us to believe that Benedict deceived the Church, publicly and repeatedly, for nearly ten years, including when he wrote in 2014 that there was “absolutely no doubt” about the validity of his act2. We do not believe that of him, and our argument does not need it.

The legal frame fails as well. Canon 335 speaks of the Roman See being “entirely impeded,” and canon 412 describes what that means for a see: a bishop so prevented by captivity, banishment, exile, or incapacity that he cannot communicate with his people even by letter3. Benedict lived freely in the Vatican for almost a decade. He wrote, gave interviews, received visitors, and corresponded openly. Whatever else his situation was, it was not that.

Finally, there is the method itself. A reading that treats every oddity as a signal can find a signal anywhere, and nothing Benedict said can ever refute it, since each denial can be read as one more coded message. An argument that no evidence could ever count against is not stronger for that reason. It has simply stopped being an argument. Ours rests on the plain sense of Benedict’s words, and it can be tested, as Part II of Essay 2 set out to test it.

II. Archbishop Viganò

Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò, the former apostolic nuncio to the United States, has argued since 2023 that Jorge Mario Bergoglio never validly became pope. His argument, however, is not about Benedict’s renunciation at all. It concerns Bergoglio’s acceptance of the papacy in 2013. In the archbishop’s words, that acceptance “is vitiated because he considers the Papacy to be something other than what it is,” and an intention to use the office against its purpose, shown by Bergoglio’s conduct before and after his election, rendered the acceptance null4.

There is an echo of our own argument here: an act vitiated because a man mistook what the papacy is. But the resemblance is on the surface. Viganò’s case depends on an intention hidden in another man’s heart, which he infers from that man’s later conduct, appealing to Our Lord’s words, “By their fruits you shall know them.” That is a rule for discernment, not a rule of law, and it cannot establish that a juridical act was void. Essay 2 declined to argue from Benedict’s fear for exactly this reason, and we decline to argue from Bergoglio’s intentions for the same one. Note, too, that Viganò’s argument would apply even if Benedict had resigned validly. It answers a different question from ours.

The archbishop’s position also reaches much further. He holds that the Second Vatican Council is “completely devoid of magisterial authority,” and he speaks of a “conciliar church” distinct from the Catholic Church, with which he says no Catholic can be in communion5. In July 2024 the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith declared that he had incurred excommunication for the delict of schism6. This series takes no position on those wider claims, and nothing in its argument depends on them. Our question is narrower: whether one act of renunciation took effect.

III. Ann Barnhardt

The American writer Ann Barnhardt should be named here with some gratitude, because she was among the first in the English-speaking world to press the argument from substantial error, and much of her case runs parallel to ours. She reads the last general audience and Archbishop Gänswein’s 2016 address as we do, insists that canon 188 sets an objective standard, and argues that the papacy, unlike holy orders, leaves no indelible mark that a resigning pope could keep7. On the practical question, too, she is sound. Asked whether a Catholic who shares her conclusion should stop going to Mass, she answers: “absolutely not8.”

Where we differ from her is not in conclusion but in scope. Barnhardt sets beside the legal argument a second line of explanation: that Benedict acted under fear and pressure from the circle of cardinals she calls the “Sankt Gallen Mafia,” and that what followed should be read in that light9. Some readers find those suspicions persuasive, and evidence not yet public may one day confirm or refute them. But they concern what happened in men’s consciences and behind closed doors, and the public record cannot prove them in law. So this series sets them aside. Our case stands or falls without them, and we would rather rest it where no critic can dismiss it as speculation.

IV. Sedevacantism

Sedevacantism holds that the Chair of Peter has been empty for decades, in most versions since the death of Pius XII in 1958. Its classic argument runs from the Church’s infallibility. The Church cannot give her children harmful doctrine or a harmful universal discipline; the post-conciliar authorities gave both, in the teaching of the Council and in the new rite of Mass; therefore those authorities could not have possessed the authority of Christ10. A related school, following the Dominican theologian Michel-Louis Guérard des Lauriers, holds that the post-conciliar claimants were designated to the papacy but never received its authority: popes materially, as the school puts it, but not formally11.

We understand why serious people have been driven to these conclusions, and we have no wish to mock them. But this series is incompatible with them at every point. Our whole argument presupposes that Benedict XVI was a true pope, validly elected in 2005 and the Vicar of Christ until his death; a sedevacantist cannot grant that premise, and so cannot use our conclusion. Our argument does not rest on any charge of heresy, and Essay 2 expressly rejected that charge even against the man whose act we criticize. And our claim is narrow where theirs is sweeping. We say that one act of renunciation, on one day, failed under the Church’s law. We do not say that the visible Church has been without a head for two generations.

There is a further difference that will matter in the next essay. The popes from John XXIII through Benedict XVI were each received by the Church peacefully, with no rival claimant and no predecessor still living in white. Whatever one thinks of their decisions, the classical principle of peaceful acceptance applies to them in its plainest form. Our argument depends precisely on the claim that 2013 was different.

V. Recognize and Resist

The last position is held by many of our readers, and it deserves the most careful statement. Many traditional Catholics, and the Society of St. Pius X most prominently, hold that the reigning pope is truly pope and name him in the Canon of the Mass, yet decline to follow him where they judge that his commands or teaching depart from Tradition. They appeal to a long theological tradition. St. Paul withstood St. Peter to his face when the truth of the Gospel was at stake, and St. Thomas teaches that when the faith is in danger, subjects may rebuke even their prelates in public12. They rely, too, on a distinction drawn by Cardinal Cajetan: to disobey the pope, even obstinately, is not schism; schism is the refusal to submit to him as head of the Church13.

We do not attack this position. It is a posture toward a true pope, rooted in Scripture and in St. Thomas, and the classical canonists give it room. Wernz and Vidal, defining schism, note that a man does not become a schismatic by the simple transgression of a papal law; otherwise every violator of the Church’s universal laws would be a schismatic14. If Benedict’s renunciation was valid, recognize-and-resist remains a position many faithful Catholics will continue to find necessary.

But it answers a different question from ours. Recognize-and-resist asks how a Catholic should treat a true pope who errs. This series asks whether a particular man holds the office at all. The two questions must be kept apart, because the answer to the second governs the first. If our argument fails, the framework of recognition and resistance stands exactly where it stood. If it succeeds, the question of resistance does not arise with respect to a man who does not hold the office, because one can neither obey nor resist a jurisdiction that was never received. Either way, we ask readers who hold this position for nothing more than a fair hearing. We do not ask them to change their practice on the strength of an argument the Church has not judged.

What We Claim, and What We Do Not

Gathered in one place, then, here is where this series stands. We claim that Benedict XVI’s renunciation of February 11, 2013, was void by the law itself for substantial error, and we claim it on the basis of what he and his secretary said in public. We claim that what follows from that, for the conclave of 2013 and for the years after it, follows by the ordinary logic of the Church’s law, and later essays will set it out.

We do not claim that Benedict planned his act as a secret message, that he lied to the Church, or that he was a heretic. We do not claim to know what anyone intended in the privacy of his conscience. We do not claim that the Chair of Peter has been empty since 1958. We do not deny the authority of an ecumenical council. We do not claim that our conclusion binds anyone, or that it settles anything the Church herself has not settled. And we do not tell any Catholic to leave the sacraments.

That leaves the weightiest objection of all: the one every serious critic of this series will raise, and the one the theologians and canonists we have quoted would themselves press most firmly. It is that the peaceful acceptance of Benedict’s successor by the whole Church closes the question. The next essay takes it up on its own terms.

Questions this raises

Is this series a version of the “Ratzinger Code”?

No. Andrea Cionci argues that Benedict deliberately staged a false resignation to create an “impeded see.” This series argues the opposite: that Benedict sincerely believed he was resigning validly and was mistaken. A deliberate plan is not an error, and Benedict, who lived and wrote freely for a decade, was never impeded in the canonical sense.

Does this series agree with Archbishop Viganò?

No. Viganò argues that Francis’s acceptance of the papacy was void because of his interior intention, inferred from his conduct, and he rejects the authority of the Second Vatican Council. This series argues only from Benedict’s public words about his own renunciation and takes no position on Viganò’s wider claims.

Is this a sedevacantist argument?

No. Sedevacantists hold that the papacy has been vacant since 1958. This series holds that Benedict XVI was a true pope, validly elected in 2005, until his death, and its argument concerns one act of renunciation, not the orthodoxy of the conciliar popes.

How does this series relate to the “recognize and resist” position?

It does not attack it. Recognize-and-resist concerns how to treat a true pope who errs, and it has deep roots in Scripture and St. Thomas. This series asks a prior question: whether a particular man holds the office at all. If the series’ argument fails, recognize-and-resist stands as it was.

Notes

  1. Andrea Cionci, “Benedict XVI’s resignation is null and void: application to Vatican tribunal,” republished at the request of the author on Pope Head (Substack), June 13, 2024; idem, Codice Ratzinger (2022).Back
  2. Benedict XVI to Andrea Tornielli, Vatican Insider (La Stampa), February 28, 2014; discussed in Essay 2, Part II, objection 2.Back
  3. Code of Canon Law (1983), cann. 335, 412.Back
  4. Viganò, statement of October 1, 2023, as quoted in Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Criminal Decree, Prot. No. 194/2024 (July 4, 2024), “In Fact,” evidence (b); see also evidence (c) and (i). Quotations of the decree follow an unofficial English translation of the Italian original.Back
  5. Viganò, statements of June 20 and June 28, 2024, as quoted in the same decree, “In Fact,” evidence (g)–(i), and the second series of evidence, (e)–(f).Back
  6. Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Criminal Decree, Prot. No. 194/2024 (July 4, 2024), “Decision.”Back
  7. Ann Barnhardt, “The Bergoglian Antipapacy: How It Happened, and How To Fix It,” barnhardt.biz, May 8, 2018.Back
  8. Barnhardt, “Cutting the Crap: 32 Questions and Blunt Answers About the Catholic Church and Antipope Bergoglio,” barnhardt.biz, q. 32.Back
  9. Barnhardt, “How It Happened”; “Cutting the Crap,” qq. 1, 3.Back
  10. See, e.g., Anthony Cekada, Traditionalists, Infallibility and the Pope (1995; rev. 2006).Back
  11. M.-L. Guérard des Lauriers, O.P., “Le Siège apostolique est-il vacant?” Cahiers de Cassiciacum 1 (1979).Back
  12. Gal 2:11; St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 33, a. 4, ad 2.Back
  13. Cajetan, commentary on Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 39, a. 1.Back
  14. F. X. Wernz and P. Vidal, Ius Canonicum, vol. VII, Ius Poenale Ecclesiasticum (Rome: Gregorian University, 1937), n. 398, p. 439.Back

Sources

  1. Andrea Cionci, “Benedict XVI’s resignation is null and void: application to Vatican tribunal,” Pope Head (June 13, 2024)
  2. Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Criminal Decree concerning Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò, Prot. No. 194/2024 (July 4, 2024)
  3. Ann Barnhardt, “The Bergoglian Antipapacy: How It Happened, and How To Fix It” (May 8, 2018)
  4. Ann Barnhardt, “Cutting the Crap: 32 Questions and Blunt Answers About the Catholic Church and Antipope Bergoglio”
  5. Anthony Cekada, Traditionalists, Infallibility and the Pope (1995; rev. 2006)
  6. M.-L. Guérard des Lauriers, O.P., “Le Siège apostolique est-il vacant?” Cahiers de Cassiciacum 1 (1979)
  7. Code of Canon Law (1983) cann. 335, 412
  8. St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 33, a. 4, ad 2
  9. Cajetan, Commentary on the Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 39, a. 1
  10. F. X. Wernz and P. Vidal, Ius Canonicum, vol. VII, Ius Poenale Ecclesiasticum (Rome, 1937) n. 398