The Peaceful Acceptance of the Church
The strongest objection to this series, stated in the words of Billot, John of St. Thomas, and Wernz, and an honest account of where it leaves the case.
Category
The office of Peter: its authority, its limits, and the crisis in the Church today.
The strongest objection to this series, stated in the words of Billot, John of St. Thomas, and Wernz, and an honest account of where it leaves the case.
How this series differs from the “Ratzinger Code,” Archbishop Viganò, Ann Barnhardt, sedevacantism, and recognize-and-resist, and why the differences matter.
Eight objections to the claim that Benedict XVI’s resignation was invalid, each stated and answered from the law of the Church and from his own words.
Benedict XVI believed he could lay down the governance of the papacy while sustaining an indelible link to the Petrine Office, and the Church’s law says a resignation made in such substantial error is invalid by the law itself.
Before asking whether Benedict XVI validly resigned, we must ask whether a Catholic may ask such a question at all. The Church’s law, her theologians, and her history answer: yes, within limits.